Below are the top 5 lists of FA Cup appearance makers and goalscorers for Hull City. The list includes substitute appearances as well as starts. The goals table excludes own goals scored by opponents for City.
Hull City – Most FA Cup Appearances
| 1. | Andy Davidson | 43 appearances | 1953 to 1967 |
| 2. | Chris Chilton | 39 appearances | 1960 to 1971 |
| 3. | Billy Bly | 35 appearances | 1946 to 1960 |
| 4. | Doug Clarke | 31 appearances | 1956 to 1964 |
| 5. | Matt Bell | 30 appearances | 1920 to 1931 |
Hull City – Most FA Cup Goals
| 1. | Chris Chilton | 16 goals | 1960 to 1971 |
| 2. | Ken Wagstaff | 14 goals | 1964 to 1975 |
| 3. | Sammy Stevens | 9 goals | 1913 to 1920 |
| 3. | Paddy Mills | 9 goals | 1922 to 1933 |
| 3. | Ken Houghton | 9 goals | 1965 to 1973 |