Below are the top 5 lists of League Cup appearance makers and goalscorers for Hull City. The list includes substitute appearances as well as starts. The goals table excludes own goals scored by opponents for City.
Hull City – Most League Cup Appearances
| 1. | Garreth Roberts | 24 appearances | 1979 to 1988 |
| 2. | Tony Norman | 22 appearances | 1980 to 1988 |
| 3. | Chris Chilton | 21 appearances | 1960 to 1970 |
| 4. | Ken Wagstaff | 19 appearances | 1965 to 1975 |
| 4. | Jeff Wealands | 19 appearances | 1972 to 1978 |
Hull City – Most League Cup Goals
| 1. | Chris Chilton | 10 goals | 1960 to 1970 |
| 2. | Ken Wagstaff | 6 goals | 1965 to 1975 |
| 2. | Billy Whitehurst | 6 goals | 1981 to 1985 |
| 4. | Dean Windass | 5 goals | 1991 to 2008 |
| 4. | David Brown | 5 goals | 1998 to 2000 |