| 1. | Andy Davidson | 579 appearances (579 starts, 0 subs) | 1952 to 1967 |
| 2. | Garreth Roberts | 487 appearances (480 starts, 7 subs) | 1979 to 1990 |
| 3. | Chris Chilton | 477 appearances (477 starts, 0 subs) | 1960 to 1971 |
| 4. | George Maddison | 456 appearances (456 starts, 0 subs) | 1924 to 1938 |
| 5. | Tony Norman | 442 appearances (442 starts, 0 subs) | 1980 to 1988 |
| 6. | Billy Bly | 438 appearances (438 starts, 0 subs) | 1939 to 1960 |
| 7. | Ken Wagstaff | 434 appearances (429 starts, 5 subs) | 1964 to 1975 |
| 8. | Matt Bell | 423 appearances (423 starts, 0 subs) | 1919 to 1931 |
| 9. | Doug Clarke | 411 appearances (411 starts, 0 subs) | 1955 to 1964 |
| 10. | Tommy Bleakley | 389 appearances (389 starts, 0 subs) | 1919 to 1930 |
| 11. | Roger DeVries | 362 appearances (358 starts, 4 subs) | 1970 to 1980 |
| 12. | Brian Bulless | 357 appearances (357 starts, 0 subs) | 1953 to 1963 |
| 13. | Ian Butler | 339 appearances (334 starts, 5 subs) | 1965 to 1973 |
| 14. | Peter Skipper | 338 appearances (335 starts, 3 subs) | 1979 to 1988 |
| 15. | Viggo Jensen | 335 appearances (335 starts, 0 subs) | 1948 to 1956 |
| 16. | Frank Banks | 334 appearances (330 starts, 4 subs) | 1967 to 1976 |
| 17. | Malcolm Lord | 333 appearances (304 starts, 29 subs) | 1967 to 1979 |
| 18. | Les Collinson | 332 appearances (331 starts, 1 subs) | 1956 to 1967 |
| 19. | Cliff Woodhead | 326 appearances (326 starts, 0 subs) | 1930 to 1939 |
| 20. | Andy Dawson | 317 appearances (306 starts, 11 subs) | 2003 to 2013 |
